中文歌SACD 值唔值得買？

oteloj

開始玩左SACD 無耐，覺得始終優勝過普通CD 唔少。最近想買反d 中文SACD, 但見到有d 師兄話中文SACD 好多都係由普通cd 整出來？！ 甘大家覺得值唔值得買，定買反K2HD CD 好d?

hksarac

80%都是搵笨，唔值，呃人嘅。就算話24/96有些都是假。

hkbg

今時唔同往日

今時今日既SACD的確有唔少流野, 音色只是加鹽加酸, 唔會比CD好
但同時K2HD, 其實咪又係加鹽加酸, 亦唔會比CD好好多
因而家非常下載既途徑真係太多, 唱片公司好少新歌出,
整來整去都係舊歌汁汁佢, 又話出K2HD, SACD,

kc7

Analogue黑膠碟年代再出SACD可能會有驚喜，80年代中期至90年代未出嘅作品再版SACD就唔好有太大期望。

bh72bh72

改個名又搵一筆！

bigmusicfan

最近出的梅艳芳的sacd，电频好高，声音吵，很不耐听。

hksarac

kc7 發表於 2015-12-24 00:15
Analogue黑膠碟年代再出SACD可能會有驚喜，80年代中期至90年代未出嘅作品再版SACD就唔好有太大期望。 ...

就算analog，唔用tape轉，一樣死得，Sony的就是呃人，16/44轉做DSD，現在自己轉都得啦！明明有好一些錄音，都是假DSD呃錢！外國的就好得多。

kl122002

自已都有一排因自已以前無, 家下可以買而就買左少少.
是不是真的很好呢.....只能說是可圈可點, 有些比較冷門而不常出的仲算keep到幾好, 反而時時以不同版本出的就真是麻麻地了.
我又唔覺XRCD, K2 真係好幾多....頂多是聲音比以前明顯的強行拉硬,  好極有限.  

yoniyama

SACD format is NOT always better, it all depends, especially on the initial recording and mastering.  Some labels are particularly bad, eg 永恒.

The same goes for other audiophile CD formats, eg XRCD, K2HD, etc.  Some are consistently good, eg Blu-spec CD2 by Sony.  I think this has more to do with the label (eg Sony) doing a high-quality recording and mastering, than the technical merit of the blu-spec CD2.

So far, based on the CD format itself, I generally have better luck with XRCD24, Blu-spec CD2, and UHQCD.  

hksarac

yoniyama 發表於 2015-12-27 11:50
SACD format is NOT always better, it all depends, especially on the initial recording and mastering. ...

Song 9成半都是假，包括網上買dSf file。


陳慧嫻隻新碟Evolve，係用24/96轉的，買得，好靚聲

rickkklam

有一間WXX出都是假的, 係佢地staff 親口講的.
佢話用master tape, 成本太貴.
只係用CD執出黎, 所以我玩2 hand vinyl.

oteloj

甘請問有咩好聲中文SACD 值得買呢

yoniyama

In my experience, canto pop SACD by some labels are particularly disappointing, such as: 風行, 東亞, and 環星.  Probably these labels do not use the original master tape to make a new glass mould for the SACD, or the original recording was really bad.  You may want to try them out before making a purchase.

UHQCD by 風行 is quite good, if you do not mind the outrageous retail price.  UHQCD in Japan is typically (officially) listed at around JY 2,000 to JY 3,000.

Usually, if a label makes an investment to use the original master tape to re-master a glass mould for the SACD, it will advertise this feat widely.    That may be another way to screen for a better quality SACD.

PS

There are just as many (if not more) disappointing LP's  being re-issued.  And the disappointment is even worse, because these re-issued LP's often cost even more than the bad SACD's.